![]() |
| Image credit: Amazon |
After the mesmerising read that was Rapture, I decided
to treat myself before jumping into the next bookclub book and so I indulged in
Matt Macnabb’s Hollywood’s Dark History.
Focusing on the era of the Silent movies and then the
Talkies, the book summarises the life, scandal, and legacy of thirteen of
Hollywood’s most famous stars. Alongside the recognisable names of Charlie
Chaplin, Mae West, Errol Flynn, and Joan Crawford whose salacious stories we
have heard about in other books and films, the book explores the lesser-known dirty
dramas of Evelyn Nesbit, Thelma Todd, Jean Harlow, Lana Turner, William Desmond
Taylor, Barbara LaMarr, Mabel Normand, Roscoe ‘Fatty’ Arbuckle, and Clara Bow.
Popular-culture historian Macbabb singles his book out from
other celebrated Hollywood scandal works, such as Hollywood Babylon, by
crafting compelling and digestible entire life stories within the confines of
2-3 pages. A brief introduction, a contextual paragraph or two about the
subject’s early life, career, and then scandals that scorched them, and finally
a closing paragraph about their death and legacy shapes each chapter. Whoever
wrote that misleading byline for Around the Table – take note, this
is what a book of short essays should look like.
Whilst predominantly written with an academic and indifferent
tone, the book is flavoured by very light injections of the narrator’s
character, usually lamenting the lost life or forgotten legacy of the book’s
subjects. Macnabb also adds a little further drama by converting the past and
present exchange rate to convey just how expensive some of these people and
their lifestyles were.
Where the book falls down is in the editing – or lack
thereof. Finding one or two misused words throughout a book is something that
happens once in a while and it’s pretty easy to float over. But there are a
number of sentences in this book that read as though they were typed up super
fast and then changed midway through, resulting in this weird amalgamation of
two different sentences strung together and it proves to be rather jarring.
There are instances where words are repeated or missed completely. If there was
any editing done on this book before publication and distribution, then it was
done by one person at 3 in the morning on the day when bulk printing was
scheduled to start. Sadly, it does lower the professional tone and jerks the
reader out of their reverie by throwing a grammatical spanner at them.
![]() |
| Image credit: Goodreads |
But ultimately, Hollywood’s Dark History: Silver Screen Scandals is an interesting and compelling non-fiction read that does inspire its readers to indulge in a little bit of a knowledge deep-dive to find out more about its subjects (at least, it did for me). Filled with lavish lifestyles, sex, violence, blackmail, murder, and all the dramas in between, it’s an entertaining and enlightening little read that I very much enjoyed.
Author: Matt Macnabb, 2019
Published: Pen and Sword History, an imprint of Pen and
Sword Books Ltd, Yorkshire, 2019






















